|“||I can see that Count Olaf is as handsome as a noble steed riding on the back of a beautiful princess. His legendary handsomeness is... is celebrated in special weekly holidays in my faraway land, please.||”|
— Gunther, "The Ersatz Elevator: Part One"
He is a pinstripe-suit wearing auctioneer. He pretends to come from another country so people believe that he doesn't speak fluent English. Olaf constantly says "please" after and in the middle of every sentence. This is also done by Madame Lulu. He wears horse riding boots to cover up his tattoo, and a monocle to distort his eyebrow. Esmé Squalor was aware of Count Olaf's identity due to being trained by him.
Count Olaf's identity is revealed when he slips on a doily and his boots and monocle come off. He and Esmé run out of the auction hall and the audience that tries to chase them get into a hopeless tangle when slipping on the doilies and tumbling down.
Gunther appears straight away when the Baudelaires open the windows to let light in. He then attempts to kill Jerome Squalor by cutting the chandelier rope but Klaus saves him. They go to a restaurant called Herring Houdini and Olaf's associates give Jerome a sleeping potion. Gunther performs a musical number called "Keep Chasing Your Schemes" at the request of Larry the Waiter.
Back at the penthouse, Esmé pushes the children down the elevator shaft. The two of them dance and then they go to the auction. He gets angry when the children fool his plan so he and Esmé run away and drive off.
Gunther wears sunglasses to cover his eyebrow, knee-high boots to cover his tattoo and fingerless gloves. He has a cane (the same one Georgina Orwell had) and he wears a pinstripe suit. He also has white hair in a ponytail.
- "I can see that Count Olaf is as handsome as a noble steed riding on the back of a beautiful princess. His legendary handsomeness is... is celebrated in special weekly holidays in my faraway land, please."
- "Pretty lady, why don't you eat here with your boring husband? I'll take the children to the herring restaurant for kidnapping. I mean hors d'oeuvres."
- "You can sleep it off on way home please. Time to hurry to penthouse to make sure that nothing has been stolen during the afternoon."
- "The auction, please, has started. As you can see, Lot Número One-o is a wanted poster for notorious good-looking villain named Count Olaf."
- "We proceed as normal, please, to the crying of Lot 49."
- In the Netflix show, Gunther uses "Please" considerably less.
"Gunther's look was inspired by Karl Lagerfeld. For the accent, I mostly tried for German, but I didn't really choose a specific town. I kind of went all over the Eurorail." - Neil Patrick Harris on Gunther.